Law expert says Buc-ee’s faces uphill battle in Beaver’s Mini Mart suit
ByMegan Finke, WHIO.com and Xavier Hershovitz
August 06, 2026 at 6:16 pm EDT
Law expert says Buc-ee’s faces uphill battle in Beaver’s Mini Mart suit Buc-ee’s is suing Beaver’s Mini Mart in Beavercreek.
ByMegan Finke, WHIO.com and Xavier Hershovitz
August 06, 2026 at 6:16 pm EDT
BEAVERCREEK — It’s the beaver brand battle that has people talking across the country.
[DOWNLOAD: Free WHIO-TV News app for alerts as news breaks ]
Buc-ee’s is suing Beaver’s Mini Mart in Beavercreek.
TRENDING STORIES:
- Coroner IDs man shot, killed during Harrison Twp. break-in
- Man seriously hurt after being hit by vehicle; Crime Stoppers offers $2K reward for information
- ‘My outlook is very positive;’ Local brewery founder gives update on recent health concerns
A law expert tells News Center 7 that she doesn’t believe a judge or jury would rule in Buc-ee’s favor.
News Center 7’s Xavier Hershovitz found out many cases don’t even make it that far.
“It’s ridiculous. It’s getting out of hand,” Darby Salyers, of Xenia, said.
That’s what Penny Jo and Darby thought when they learned Buc-ee’s was suing the mini mart over copyright infringement.
“Absolutely petty and ridiculous. They’ve been here over 20 years. I mean, this is part of our life,” Penny Jo Bilbrey, of Spring Valley, said.
News Center 7 wanted to get a legal perspective on the beaver-brand battle.
Hershovitz talked with University of Michigan law professor Jessica Litman. She focuses on intellectual property law.
“Trademark infringement requires the trademark owner to prove that the marks are sufficiently similar that consumers are likely to be confused,” Litman said.
She said Buc-ee’s has filed several lawsuits against businesses for copyright infringement.
“When Buc-ee’s started a national expansion, it started filing trademark suits against other convenience stores attached to gas stations that it saw in the way of its expansion, and it’s been something of a bully,” Litman said.
When looking at the two logos, Litman said she finds it unlikely that it would “be able to prove a likelihood of confusion.”
But she said these lawsuits are very expensive.
While she believes no judge or jury would rule in Buc-ee’s favor, getting to that point can be tough for small businesses.
“A number of businesses have decided that it’s way too expensive to go to trial on this, and have settled by agreeing to change their neighbor logo,” she said.
Bilbrey thinks the lawsuit is “a waste of time.”
They’re focused on the way the community has come together to support the mini mart.
There’s a GoFundMe to help with legal fees. At last check, it’s raised over $27,000.
News Center 7 will continue to follow this story.
[SIGN UP: WHIO-TV Daily Headlines Newsletter ]
0
View Comments
Win $2,000 with WHIO Radio's Back To School Contest
Most Read
Police searching for two women accused of stealing from Target
Law expert says Buc-ee’s faces uphill battle in Beaver’s Mini Mart suit
Former Ohio State football player avoids prison time after admitting to 9 bank robberies
Candy store closing due to lack of foot traffic, lower profits
7 in custody after police chase in Montgomery County
Twitter Widget Iframe
Read Original at WHIO TV →