Jul 9, 2026 8:23am PT
New York Times and Other News Outlets Accuse OpenAI of Lying in Discovery, Demand Legal Sanctions Against AI Giant
Plus Icon
Corbin Bolies
Latest
-
Fidji Simo, OpenAI’s No. 2 Executive, to Step Down to Focus on Recovery From Chronic Illness 7 hours ago
-
New York Times and Other News Outlets Accuse OpenAI of Lying in Discovery, Demand Legal Sanctions Against AI Giant 15 hours ago
Getty Images
The New York Times and several news outlets on Thursday filed a motion for sanctions against OpenAI, accusing the company of concealing its ability to search the training datasets and output logs for its models for more than two years as they sought company documents.
The motion’s plaintiffs included the Times, the Daily News, the Center for Investigative Reporting, the Intercept and digital publisher and CNET parent Ziff Davis. The 52-page document, filed in the U.S. District Court in the Southern District of New York, claimed that OpenAI’s lying only came to light after a second deposition from Vinnie Monaco, who leads privacy engineering at the company. In that February deposition, the outlets said Monaco revealed OpenAI had searched training datasets and output data despite the company’s initial claims that it couldn’t access that data. The outlets also alleged OpenAI deleted logs, a violation of the court’s preservation orders.
Related Stories
Cannes Breakout Comedy ‘Jim Queen’ Closes Key Deals Ahead of Annecy Screening (EXCLUSIVE)
Variety Toasts French Cinema With Post-Cannes Summer Dinner at Paris' Laperouse With Thierry Fremaux, Guillaume Canet, Pierre-Antoine Capton, Rebecca Zlotowski and Anamaria Vartolomei
“Instead of just producing that evidence at the start of the case and focusing on the merits of its fair use defense, OpenAI chose obstruction,” the news organizations, through their attorneys, wrote.
Popular on Variety
The outlets asked the court to recognize the company made false claims and deleted output logs, award them attorneys’ fees and impose any other punishment the court deems fit.
“Each of the remedies requested is an appropriate exercise of this Court’s inherent authority and necessary both in response to OpenAI’s misconduct and as a deterrent to those who might contemplate following their example,” the outlets added.
An OpenAI spokesperson said the Times was “persisting with their efforts to invade the privacy of people who have nothing to do with this case, including by making these blatantly false allegations.”
“We’ll continue defending our users’ privacy and the long-established principles of fair use,” the spokesperson said in a statement.
Crosby, lead attorney for the New York Times, said in a statement that OpenAI “lied to The Times, The Daily News Plaintiffs, the public, and the court.”
“It claimed searching ChatGPT outputs for copies of The Times’ and the Daily News Plaintiffs’ content was infeasible, burdensome, and invasive of users’ privacy – while at the same time concealing that it had already done such searches,” said Crosby, a partner at Susman Godfrey. “If OpenAI genuinely believed that copying our clients’ journalism was fair and legal, it wouldn’t have hid the truth about having done it.”
The Times sued OpenAI and Microsoft in 2023, becoming the first news outlet to bring legal action against the generative AI company to protect its copyright. The Daily News, Center for Investigative Reporting and Ziff Davis filed separate suits in 2024 alleging similar behavior. The Times has spent more than $28 million on litigation costs against AI companies, $4.2 million of which came during 2026’s first financial quarter.
Many news outlets have tried to walk a line between protecting their work and partnering with AI companies for licensing opportunities as AI chatbots and summaries eat into digital traffic and the advertising dollars that accompany it. The Times, which has also sued AI company Perplexity for similar alleged infringement, struck a content-licensing deal with Amazon for “AI-related uses” last year, and it is also developing its own use cases for the technology within its newsroom.
Shaquille O’Neal, TNT Sports and Authentic Studios Announce Premiere Date for ‘Dunkman,’ Professional Dunk League (EXCLUSIVE)
‘The Gentlemen’ Sets Season 2 Release Date at Netflix
‘Hope’ Trailer: Giant Alien Monsters, Crashing Spaceships and Wild Gun Battles Create Carnage in Neon’s Insane Korean Sci-Fi Action-Thriller
Netflix Sets Golf Drama ‘Jupiter Island’ From ‘Love Story’ Creator and A24
‘Spy School’ TV Series in the Works at Disney+, Ryan Reynolds’ Maximum Effort to Produce
Showrunner Mara Brock Akil’s Writers’ Colony Announces Cohorts for 2026 Summer and Fall Residencies
Loading comments...
More From Our Brands
- Rolling Stone\
De La Rose and Ryan Castro Throw a Cross-Cultural Party on ‘La Monda’\
\
- Robb Report\
Corvette Buyers Are Snapping Up the Pricier New Grand Sport\
\
- Sportico\
Hoops Players’ Win Tops Big Day in NCAA Eligibility Litigation\
\
- WWD\
Thousands of Shoppers Just Bought This $17 Adidas Duffel for Travel and the Gym\
\
ad
PMC
Variety is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2026 Variety Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Variety and the Flying V logos are trademarks of Variety Media, LLC.
Our Sites
Read Original at Variety →